C&T 5004 Raghu Betina

Blog #2

What key challenges will you face in putting your vision for an effective learning environment into practice?

In this reflection:

  1. Describe 3–4 elements of your vision, including one that would be easier to implement and one that would be more challenging. Consider how they could extend beyond a single site.
  2. Explain which elements fit or conflict with the grammar of schooling, situating your discussion in a particular context and drawing explicitly on 3–4 course concepts.
  3. Illustrate the opportunities and challenges with 2–3 examples from your experience, the readings, or news and research.

Focus on the broader institutional, cultural, and political factors that shape change, and make original connections to the course ideas.

I came into this semester with an idea and a rough plan for organizing my introductory programming course like an open-world role-playing game: a main campaign and side quests. Blog #1 described that pre-existing plan, with some new ideas from the early readings. Since then, the readings on the grammar of schooling and the challenges of change have led me to revise the plan substantially. My teaching follows the quarter system, starting about a month after this course. I am implementing the revised plan in my own classroom starting this week, and we will continue to course correct as we go.

In previous versions of my MBA course, students entered with wildly different backgrounds but faced the same assignments and deadlines. Experienced students might finish an assignment in one or two hours; beginners might need six to ten. In my experience, beginners who earn an A often find the time and initiative to repeat early material and seek help. Much of that additional foundational work received no credit. My hypothesis is that recognizing it can make the course fairer than its previous arrangement.

The revised plan has four elements: a shared main campaign leading to a fully functional, portfolio-worthy app; additional foundational practice for credit; credit-bearing extensions connected to students’ interests; and flexible pathways within a course that retains required deadlines and shared classroom activities. Completing the main campaign will earn roughly 80 points, or a B-minus. Higher grades will require side quests. A beginner could practice arrays and loops, while an experienced student could explore music synthesis, games, or visual design.

Working within the grammar of schooling

Some parts fit the existing grammar of schooling reasonably well. We retain a course, letter grades, a shared core, and a common outcome. Required deadlines, late penalties, and shared classroom activities also give the individual pathways a familiar structure. Tyack and Cuban describe how schools “award grades and ‘credits’ as evidence of learning” (1995, p. 85). I am using that familiar structure to give students more ways to earn credit.

The harder part may be changing what people believe deserves a higher grade. Can additional practice of the basics count as a legitimate route to an A? Can different students do different work while the grading system remains understandable and credible? Keeping letter grades does not automatically mean the proposal fits everyone’s expectations about achievement.

We also need to balance the game. Our rubric rates each unit on “lift”—how much work it requires—and “importance,” based roughly on how many other units depend on it, combined with our subjective judgment. We multiply those ratings to get the unit’s weight. This is our first guess, and we expect to revise it.

Some advanced students may choose foundational material to score easy points and skip later units they would have completed under the previous system. There could be net losses in learning for some students. Are the potential gains for others worth that risk? Resnick and Hall distinguish learning-oriented goals from performance-oriented goals, emphasizing that achievement goals affect the kind of effort learners make (1998, pp. 105–106). Credit may help students prioritize practice, but we still need to examine whether their choices serve their learning.

How can individual pathways work within a shared course?

The Dalton Plan offers a close historical precedent: minimum tasks, additional choices, individual pacing, and higher grades for more or better work. But its limited adoption and decline in U.S. public schools are a warning. Teachers faced substantial paperwork and demands on their time; some students struggled with motivation or found solitary work boring; and the plan challenged familiar school structures (Tyack & Cuban, 1995, p. 96). These difficulties help identify what this design needs to support.

One important difference concerns teacher workload. Content authoring is centralized: I write the shared materials, much like a textbook, and individual teachers are welcome to contribute improvements or additions in a model similar to open-source software development. Individual teachers can use the shared materials without maintaining separate content for each student’s pathway. Automatic grading and Study Buddy, our course-integrated AI tutor, were already part of my course infrastructure. They make varied submission schedules manageable and help students get unstuck. We are also developing Study Buddy’s ability to help students choose pathways. Teachers would still provide guidance and identify learning difficulties. Together, these supports contribute to the capacity needed for individualized learning.

Student independence still needs structure, even though my learners are adults. Having the same deadlines can push some students forward before they master a concept, making subsequent concepts increasingly difficult. In an earlier version of the course, I tried removing deadlines altogether, and students procrastinated until catching up became very difficult. Required units will therefore retain deadlines to keep students moving and ready for group activities. Students can submit repeatedly, with late penalties applying only to points earned after the deadline. Unit videos also help them keep moving through the content.

Social connection is also essential. We place substantial emphasis on office hours, study groups, and shared class activities. Talking with students helps me notice shaky foundations and guide them toward useful practice. I want our precious classroom time to build community and enrich learning, alongside asynchronous access to the critical content.

For institutional fit, the design operates within an existing course, grading system, and academic calendar. Tyack and Cuban describe how selected Dalton practices survived through adaptations within conventional schools (1995, p. 97). That offers a useful direction for this experiment: individual pathways within familiar structures. Whether these responses are sufficient remains an open question.

What would it take to work elsewhere?

Hatch’s account of fit among an innovation’s goals, capabilities, and local conditions helps frame the next step (2021, pp. 451–453). I have proposed a meeting with a City Colleges of Chicago contact to discuss a possible pilot, but it is not yet scheduled. They have described a need for technical-pathway content and difficulty attracting faculty with substantial experience in some technical areas. Self-contained content, Study Buddy, and materials that help teachers teach while getting up to speed could respond to those needs. The fit will have to be explored with them.

Payne’s discussion makes trust especially relevant. He describes how attempts to replicate successful practices can overlook the skilled faculty, shared commitments, and relationships that made them work (2008, p. 63). I have offered to help teach the first pilot myself, potentially serving essentially as a TA alongside a willing faculty member. Working together could help us build trust, learn what needs adapting, and develop local capacity and ownership. Fullan argues that effective change requires those elements alongside good ideas: “being right is not by itself a strategy of change” (2015, p. 41).

Based on my 15 years of teaching experience, my intuition tells me this might work, and I hope it does. But I need to guard against seeing only the results I want to see. I want to pay attention to where the design falls short, who benefits, and who might lose out. As we revise the design during the quarter, I want to learn whether beginners gain a more attainable route to higher grades through useful practice, whether experienced students pursue worthwhile extensions, and whether another institution can sustain the approach. Recognizing learning students already need to do seems like a promising place to start.

References

Fullan, M. (2015). The new meaning of educational change (5th ed.). Teachers College Press.

Hatch, T. (2021). We will now resume our regular programming. Journal of Educational Change, 22(3), 447–456.

Payne, C. M. (2008). So much reform, so little change: The persistence of failure in urban schools. Harvard Education Press.

Resnick, L. B., & Hall, M. W. (1998). Learning organizations for sustainable education reform. Daedalus, 127(4), 89–118.

Tyack, D., & Cuban, L. (1995). Tinkering toward utopia: A century of public school reform. Harvard University Press.