Blog #1
For this assignment, please think about a learning experience that you would describe as being particularly effective for you, your children, your students or someone else you know. This could take place inside school or in another setting (including an online setting) and it could involve learners of any age.
Before you start writing, take a few moments to try to picture and remember (or imagine):
- What happened?
- Who was involved and what were they doing?
- Where did it take place?
- What did it look like there?
- What did it feel like?
- What was learned?
Please:
- Describe the experience
- Share some of the key elements that you think made the experience effective
- Explain why you think they helped make the experience so effective
Before I imagine a particularly effective learning experience, let me share some background about my teaching and some conundrums I’ve encountered.
I teach an introductory programming class at the MBA level for non-programmers to become literate in full-stack app development, so that they can go on to become more effective founders, product managers, investors, etc.
People come into class with widely varying levels of prior experience. Most MBAs, especially when I first started teaching this course ~13 years ago, had never seen a line of code before. But many students do have experience in one part of the stack or another (SQL, HTML, CS, etc.), even though they’d never done full-stack development. Nowadays, it’s quite likely that students have seen e.g. Python or JavaScript in high school or their early college years. Still, the course is designed assuming no prior programming experience.
So, we start from zero. The goal is to get to the point where you can design, build, and deploy a real app. I teach as little as we can possibly get away with about each topic because we have so much to cover in such a short amount of time, and I don’t want to overwhelm students who truly are beginners.
The learning experience I want to try this quarter keeps that shared starting point but gives students choices after the required path. A beginner who needs more practice could choose additional work on arrays and loops. A student who wants a bigger challenge could choose game programming, electronic music, or visual design. Both students would be working toward the same course goals, but they would not have to spend their time in the same place.
Here are some conundrums I’ve encountered over the years:
Problem #1: moving at the same pace
The students who come in with some background are able to finish early assignments in 1–2 hours, whereas true beginners might need 6–10 hours.
Some advanced students work ahead, but most (understandably) hew to the assigned due dates.
Problem #2: some students could use more reps
For true beginners, lots of repetitions of basic concepts (variables, arrays, loops, etc) would be very useful.
But I don’t want to require so many reps of the basics for all students, because it would be tedious for students who don’t need them.
Problem #3: no one does optional material
When I make additional reps of foundational topics available as optional assignments, very few students do them, even the ones who could benefit a lot from them.
On the flip side: advanced students have frequently asked me for more material to work on. They tell me they really love this programming and app-development thing, and would love to be more ambitious about their final projects.
Yet when I make extra topics available as optional assignments, very few of those same students complete them. When I ask why, students have candidly told me that they have a thousand and one demands on their time. If something is optional, it’s going to fall to the bottom of their to-do list.
They have asked me for some way to get credit for the extra assignments.
Problem #4: people are inspired by different things
You can do a lot with programming, and different things inspire different learners. For example, many students, especially younger ones, want to learn game programming.
Or, there is a great, beginner-friendly platform for producing electronic music that is very effective at hooking a subset of learners and is excellent for reinforcing foundational concepts.
Some learners fall in love with the visual design aspects of programming. We could go much further down that path than we currently have time for.
However, given our time constraints, I can’t require these tangential paths for everyone. Together with what I discussed above about very few students completing optional assignments, it didn’t seem worth the time to build out these other content paths.
A potential solution: open-world learning
I imagine a learning experience that might mitigate some of the above problems: students would choose their own path through the content, earning credit for everything they do.
The units would be worth experience points. One dimension of the points would reflect the lift of the assignment—roughly how many hours it takes—and the other would reflect the importance of the concept: how many later concepts depend on it and how central it is to full-stack app development. We have data on how long students take to complete each lesson, so the first dimension could be grounded in that data. Music synthesis, for example, might be less central than arrays, which are fundamental to almost everything else.
I’m taking inspiration from open-world video games. Such games often have a main campaign that you have to complete in order to beat it, but many times there are also side quests that you can do if you want to, but you don’t have to.
The new learning experience would be like that. The idea is that there’s a main campaign, and if you do only that, you get roughly a B. If you want to get better than a B, then you have to choose some side quests. You can pick your own interest: if you want to learn how to create digital music, create games, or do visual design to a more advanced level, then you can choose to do so.
I speculate that this will give students more agency and ownership over their learning. It could allow more achievement for students who come in with more experience while still not overwhelming people who come in with no experience.
Students can also elect to do assignments that are just more reps of the foundational concepts. They don’t have to go deeper into any subjects.
An experiment
There are lots of questions to be answered about this approach. Prior art must be investigated, concerns about workload have to be resolved. Logistics, e.g., the grading burden it would create, have to be figured out. And metrics for measuring success have to be determined.
But I think the approach has enough potential that I want to try it this Fall quarter. At worst, everyone will choose the same units and we’re no worse off than before (I think?). But at best, some students will get more of the foundational reps they need, and others will be able to advance further and build more impressive portfolio projects than in the past.